Marshals Season 2 Finally Introduces A Real Villain, But Doesn't Use Him Enough

CBS

"Marshals" has struggled with a few things since its March 2026 debut, and one of its biggest problems is the lack of a compelling villain. Thankfully, Season 2, Episode 3 "Falling Sky," introduces a new character that looks like a promising potential antagonist for Luke Grimes' Kayce Dutton and his Marshals team. Sadly, he's barely in the episode.

"Marshals" Season 1 wasn't really sure what it was about, which meant we got a bewildering number of storylines, some of which never went anywhere while others just sort of fizzled out. "Marshals" Season 1, Episode 3 introduced us to a powerful and previously unseen Dutton family rival in Michael Cudlitz's Randall Clegg and his family of sovereign citizen rebels. At the time, it appeared as though the show was setting up a major recurring villain who might even known some Dutton family secrets. Then, in Episode 9, Clegg was arrested and hauled away by the authorities, never to be seen again.

After that, "Marshals" pivoted, revealing that Chris Mulkey's rancher Tom Weaver had been the season's big bad the entire time. Unfortunately, it was all a bit too late, and when Season 2 began, Weaver was dealt with as swiftly as Clegg before him. Now, the show is without an overarching villain, but the introduction of a shifty little tech bro character named Gavin Escher in Season 2, Episode 3 suggests we might finally get what we've been waiting for.

CBS

Marhsals Season 2 started with a disappointing premiere, but "Falling Sky" is more promising. It begins with a military drone being shot at by three unidentified individuals on the Broken Rock Reservation. We later learn that the trio actually managed to bring down the drone, which crashed into the home of a Broken Rock resident, killing him.

Soon, Air Force Colonel Brooks arrives at Marshals HQ and introduces Pete Calvin (Logan Marshall-Green) and Kayce Dutton to Gavin Escher, CEO of Horus Avionics. His company is developing surveillance drones for the military, and testing them in the skies over Broken Rock. Turns out it was their drone that came down on the Res.

When Escher, Cal, and Kayce meet, the tension is immediately obvious, with the Horus CEO trying to undermine the Marshals. "You guys are really on the cutting edge here, huh," he says with a smarmy grin. "If I ever lose a cow, I know where to come." Escher seems more impressed after being told that Cal and Kayce are former Navy SEALs, but he continues to butt heads with Kayce, who plays down the loss of the drone and calls attention to the death of a Broken Rock resident. Escher then shows the group a video of the three shooters who brought down the drone and the colonel asks Pete and Kayce to bring them in. When Escher suggests the Marshals are "out of their depth," Cal assures the colonel he can complete the mission.

That's it for Escher, who soon disappears and isn't seen for the rest of the episode. That's a shame, as his clash with Cal and Kayce is one of the best moments in "Falling Sky," and is far more compelling than any scenes featuring previous villains.

Fred Hayes/CBS

The big villain reveal at the end of "Marshals" Season 1 highlighted the show's biggest weakness. Specifically, it reminded viewers that the series has far too much going on and simply doesn't have time to build up a compelling villain. With Season 2, the writers have a chance to rectify that, and Gavin Escher seems perfect for the job.

For one thing, his unearned tech bro confidence is all too familiar in 2026. That makes Escher feel like a far more relevant villain than the shady ranchers and off-grid fanatics of Season 1. What's more, as Pete Calvin says later in the episode, Escher has a direct line to the White House, which introduces real stakes to the equation. Meanwhile, his drones clearly pose a real threat to the Broken Rock Reservation that could make for an interesting ongoing battle between the Marshals, Broken Rock, and Horus Avionics. Then there's the fact that the actor portraying Escher does a solid job of projecting a slimy self-importance that has already rubbed Kayce Dutton the wrong way. It would be great to see more of him as the season goes on, but the show needs to devote the time to developing his character in order for this villain story to pay off.

For now, the show is clearly trying to keep things slightly more focused. "Marshals" Episode 2 suggested that overlooked "Yellowstone" alum Tate Dutton (Brecken Merrill) might finally get a storyline this season, and Episodes 2 and 3 both make use of a "Yellowstone" tradition by featuring a Buffalo as a symbol of Kayce's ongoing struggles to keep Tate from following in his family's footsteps. If Escher plays a more prominent role as the season goes on, "Marshals" might start to resemble a decent show.